The U.S. Department of Education has abandoned key legal appeals defending a controversial rule that would have restricted eligibility for the Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) program, delivering a significant victory for millions of student loan borrowers working in government and nonprofit roles.
On or around October 21–22, 2026, the Justice Department filed joint stipulations dismissing two of three appeals related to the rule. This leaves in place June 30, 2026, district court rulings that vacated the regulation before it could take effect on July 1. A third appeal, in a companion case brought by a coalition of 22 states plus the District of Columbia, remained pending at the time of the filings, though advocates expected it might also be dropped.
The rule, finalized in late October 2025 following a Trump administration executive order, would have given Education Secretary Linda McMahon authority to disqualify government agencies and nonprofit employers from PSLF if their activities were deemed to have a “substantial illegal purpose.” Targeted conduct included support for undocumented immigrants, provision of gender-affirming care for minors, and other activities the administration viewed as unlawful. Critics argued the vague language risked politicizing a long-standing bipartisan program and potentially denying forgiveness to borrowers at schools, hospitals, legal aid groups, and other public-service organizations.
U.S. District Judge Myong J. Joun of Massachusetts struck down the rule, finding that the Education Department exceeded its statutory authority, that the regulation was unconstitutionally vague, and that it threatened First Amendment free-speech protections by linking eligibility to an employer’s viewpoint or activities. A parallel ruling came from a D.C. federal judge in a related nonprofit-led case. The program, which forgives remaining federal student loan balances after 10 years of qualifying payments for eligible public-service workers, has already canceled debt for more than 1 million borrowers and currently enrolls roughly 2.5 million participants holding over $200 billion in loans.

Forbes senior contributor Adam Minsky highlighted the development in an October 23, 2026, article headlined “23 Million Student Loan Borrowers Get Huge Win Against Education Department In Loan Forgiveness Fight,” framing it as a major setback for the department’s efforts to narrow the program. Borrower advocates and plaintiffs, including the National Council of Nonprofits, described the outcome as vindication. Diane Yentel, the council’s president and CEO, stated that the decision confirms PSLF “remains as Congress designed it.” Dan Zibel of Student Defense called the administration’s effort “anti-democratic and unlawful from the start” and a victory for public servants. California Attorney General Rob Bonta and other state officials echoed that the rule had sought to turn a bipartisan promise into a political tool.
With the appeals largely withdrawn and the rule remaining vacated, current PSLF eligibility rules stay in place for the time being. Borrowers pursuing forgiveness continue to face separate operational challenges, including payment-count adjustments and processing delays reported in recent months, but the immediate threat of employer disqualification based on the new criteria has receded. The department offered no public explanation for dropping the appeals, with court filings simply noting that each side would bear its own costs.
This outcome marks a notable retreat by the administration on one front of its broader student-loan policy agenda, which has included changes to repayment plans, loan limits, and other administrative shifts. For the millions of public-sector workers who rely on PSLF as a pathway out of debt, the court victories and subsequent drop of the appeals provide near-term stability in program rules.
