Jill Behrman’s Killer To Stay Locked Up

Attorney General Todd Rokita and his team have successfully ensured that the criminal who murdered Indiana University student Jill Behrman in 2000 will remain behind bars.

“The wheels of justice might turn slowly at times, but we take comfort in knowing we have achieved the proper outcome in this case,” Rokita said. “This vicious predator attacked and killed a young woman out innocently enjoying a bike ride, and Jill’s family since that time has endured a long and drawn-out investigatory and legal process. They will always mourn their loss, but we pray that God will grant them a measure of closure and peace.”

A U.S. district court this week denied a habeas petition filed by John Myers challenging his conviction for Behrman’s murder.

Behrman’s remains were found in 2003, three years after her disappearance. Myers was arrested and convicted in 2006.

In 2019, the U.S. district court initially granted Myers’s habeas petition, reversing his conviction and ordering a new trial. His attorneys repeatedly pushed for his early release from prison, even citing COVID-19 concerns in 2020. But the Office of the Attorney General successfully appealed that decision, and the case was remanded for more proceedings — leading ultimately to this week’s decision.

Rokita thanked his criminal appeals team, and specifically Assistant Section Chief Jesse Drum, for their work on this case.